10 May 2006


Thoughts on the West Virginia primary election

Category
General

Topic
none

The election was filled with many surprises. Maybe all of your predictions came true, but several of mine certainly did not.

I thought the race between Dave Higgins and Erik Wells for Senate in the 8th district was going to be close, but Erik pulled off a stunning victory. Higgins outspent Wells, but Wells, a former television anchor, proved that name recognition is worth its weight in gold.

Now the battle for Kanawha County is between Erik Wells and republican Mark Plants. Because Wells is a rabid left-winger (we’re talking a Hillary Clinton, Cindy Sheehan, no holds barred liberal) Plants’ chances are better against him than the conservative-leaning Higgins. But do not be fooled. Wells will not have the blowout against Plants like he had with Higgins. Republicans will be voting too and many of the conservative democratic voters do not like the nanny government Wells aspires to bring. Besides, as a former football star and hometown hero, Plants has his own name recognition.

In the 9th Senatorial district (Raleigh, Wyoming) Democrats cast an interesting vote for gambling when they gave the nod to Mark Green, a greyhound breeder and gambling lobbyist. His opponents were Delegate Sally Susman and former senator Bill Wooten.

This was another surprise to me. I did not think the dark horse (no pun intended) had a chance against “Turnpike Sally” and a former office holder. Maybe democrats are tired of the “same ol’ same ol’.”

Regardless of the opponent, republican Senator Russ Weeks is coming back to Charleston. The senator has been very attentive to the needs of his constituents and has fought for them during his tenure. He has earned a trust that they will certainly reciprocate at the polls.

Speaking of ditching the old, House Majority Leader Rick Staton (District 22) is out of a job and so his Speaker Pro Temp John Pino (District 29). While each man had individual problems in their races, I think this is a sign that incumbents who support the destructive trends of our state need to be worried. Senate Majority Leader Truman Chafin barely beat Greg “Hootie” Smith by 153 votes in Mingo County (District 6).

Democrat incumbent Delegate Linda Hrutkay (District 19) also got the boot. As one of the top liberals in the House all I have to say is goodbye and good riddance. She will not be missed.

Mike Callaghan beat Mark Hunt and Richie Robb for the honor of being stomped by Congresswoman Shelley Moore Capito. While Callaghan will give her the most trouble, I do not think Capito has anything to worry about.

Hiram Lewis failed to carry his home county, or any county for that matter, against John Raese for U.S. Senate. The battle was not even close as republicans everywhere breathed a sigh of relief.

For all of you future candidates out there taking notes, being unscrupulous negates a $1,000,000 dollar war chest.

Senator Byrd will have a real fight with Raese, but I think his biggest battle is his health. The democratic leadership in this state is hoping Byrd will hang on until after the election. That way, if the Lord retires him in office, a democrat can be nominated in his place and allowed time to do enough senatorial things while in office to win reelection. I suspect that Manchin wants Byrd’s job. Although I cannot imagine his ego allowing him any position other than Emperor of the Entire Universe (EEU).

Now that Hiram has lost, he needs to donate all his campaign money to the Republican Party who sorely needs it. Seeing as we got into this enormous debt while he was Finance Director for the party, I would say it is the least he could do.

Eric Anderson moved on in the democratic primary for House of Delegates in the 16th district. Eric, a young man in his mid-20s, was an intern for the Senate President and Majority Leader during the 2006 legislative session. It was while serving there that he decided to run.

I got to know Eric during his stint at the capitol. He is well liked and friendly to all and we had a good relationship. One day I lightheartedly told him I would support his race if he answered two questions for me.

“Do you agree with Governor Manchin’s assessment that West Virginia is in 50th place,” I asked.

“Yeah, I guess,” he replied.

So far so good.

“And who has been in control of this state,” I continued, “for the last 70 years?”

A high-ranking democrat was within earshot and blurted out, “Don’t answer that!” The democrat then tried to argue the point with me and I never got an answer from Eric.

I wish Eric the best in the world. While my support is naturally for the republicans, I do hope Eric finishes first between his democratic cohorts.

And finally, I lost my race for Republican State Executive Committee Member. I really enjoyed putting my name on the ballot. As they say, fools names and fools faces are always seen in public places.

I appreciated the support of my friends, family, and readers of this website. Many people came to me to not only say they were voting for me, but that they were asking their friends to do the same. I even had a soldier in Iraq tell me he was calling his family in Putnam County to tell them to vote for me. The whole experience was enjoyable and very humbling. Thank you.

Both of my opponents were incumbents and I did no campaigning, so I am very proud of my 822 votes.

Oh, and do not feel too bad for me. I was down for a little while but then I ate a pint of ice cream and I am quite recovered.

Comments

10:33 pm - 10 May 2006

Good call on Hiram Lewis. I was happy to see Troy Andes win his primary. Andes and I are 1999 Camp Lincoln graduates, so it’s pretty neat to see him make the big leap.

3:08 am - 11 May 2006

Wow, it took less than 24 hours to play the frail old man in poor health card. Combined with Elizabeth Dole’s remarks that Byrd voted against supporting the troops (he voted against Halliburton not troops), it should be an interesting mudslinging battle.

However, if Raese couldn’t beat Jay Rockefeller at his lowest point of popularity riding the coattails of Ronald Reagan, then there is no way he’s going to defeat Senator Byrd - especially not in a non-presidential election year.

In addition to their low approval ratings, Republicans won’t even be on the ballot in many races in many counties, so those folks will just stay home on election day. In 1984 they went to the polls to vote for Reagan. In 2006 those voters will stay home. Not to mention that Senator Byrd has always been more popular with voters than Sen. Rockefeller, so the chances of this election being as close as 1984 are slim.

One final point, Senator Byrd received 155,394 votes on Tuesday compared to only 46,259 for John Raese. That’s over 3 times the number of votes. If every single voter who cast a ballot for any of the Republican candidates (Raese, Lewis, etc.) or the other Democratic candidate voted for John Raese, Senator Byrd would still win by 50,000 votes (155,394 to 105,464). That’s a 18 point (59% to 41%) victory.

Doug Stinson
10:17 am - 11 May 2006

First, how did you get my email? Second, tell me/us a little bit about you. Who you are what you do and how you came to this. I’m willing to listen if I know you have some credibility.

As to comments. I believe it is time for some Republicans to win in the 30th District. Look at Phil Raines and Mike Stuart to do well. Both solid conservatives, family men, articulate, and well spoken who understand business, taxes, and people.

Yes, I pray and will work hard to get Plants elected over Wells. My hope is Dave Higgins, who ran a good race, will come out in support of Plants for whom he has MUCH more in common than he does with Wells (D).

I agree Raese can and will give Byrd a good race. If people listen, they will find Raese, even if rich, has more in common with them in terms of beliefs of governments role in their lives.

Last, Kanawha Co. School Board election. Everything stays the same. This is good. They system is in good hands. While Thaw got the most votes, he is ALWAYS outvoted 4-1 on each issue. He is more interested in notoriety than helping students, teachers, and parents. Barbara Welch is solid, caring and a fighter and the rest are managing well. The real issue in schools is when will we start holding parents accountable and give more authority to Principals.

Thanks.

10:26 am - 11 May 2006

Holywriter: I have yet to meet Troy, but I’m excited about his campaign as well. We need our generation in the political process.

Jim:
1) Have you seen Senator Byrd lately? He is a frail old man in poor health. Believing otherwise is delusional. The last time I saw him he was on two canes and had to be helped up two steps and he grabbed the podium with a death-grip lest he fall over. It’s not mudslinging, it’s called the truth.

BTW, I didn’t say Byrd was unqualified because he is old. In fact, I don’t believe that to be true.

2) I didn’t say Raese could beat Byrd. I said he would give him a “real fight.”

3) Your assertion that “Republicans won’t be on the ballot in many races in many counties” is inaccurate.

Besides Raese, Republicans are on the ballot for:

3 of 3 Congressional districts
13 of 17 State Senate districts
50 of 58 House of Delegates districts

Every Republican voter in this state will have at least 2 Republicans to vote for.

4) History has proven you cannot use votes received during the primary election as evidence of what will occur in the general election. Nice try though.

9:30 pm - 13 May 2006

‘Every Republican voter in this state will have at least 2 Republicans to vote for.”

Wow, 2 whole Republicans to vote for. You must be so proud.

I like Kim Wolfe, but if you think that his coattails will be similar to President Ronald Reagan then you are delusional. The same goes for what’s his name in the First Congressional District.

I’ll stand by statement “Republicans won’t be on the ballot in many races in many counties” (emphasis added). Having 2 Republicans on the ballot isn’t enough - too many races won’t have ANY Republican to choose. You’re missing 24% of the State Senate races and 14% of the House races, plus even more local and county races. That counts as “many races” in my book.

Bill Douglas
8:35 am - 15 May 2006

I don’t understand why people are making a big deal about Raese’s wealth. It doesn’t bother them that Sen. Jay Rockefeller is estimated to have a networth around $200 million.

The fact of the matter is that the majority of members of the U.S. Senate are millionaires. They’re successful in their chosen field.

Add your comment

Don't forget to
stay on topic,
play nice,
not be snarky,
obey all rules,
or your comment will
magically disappear.




Add your comment (see what others are saying)




Subscribe without commenting

William Stewart
William Stewart served 5 years as aide to leading West Virginia Senators and is a leading online commentator in West Virginia politics.

This site is where over 40,000 people come each month to get the latest political news and commentary [...]

Greenville SC real estate

Related posts
Subscribe