4 January 2006


False hope on the front page

Category
General

Topic
none

You know the story by now. After endless hours of waiting, the families and friends of miners trapped in the Sago mine rejoiced. 12 of 13 miners were alive. One cannot imagine the pandemonium inside the little Baptist church. “The miners are coming to the church so you can hug them,” they were told, “and then to the hospital.”

The repercussions of joy from Tallmansville, WV, were felt across the country and even through the world. “They’re alive!” our country’s premier papers proclaimed.

Darlene Groves, sister-in-law to one of the minors, asked Governor Manchin if the news was true. “Are all 12 men alive?” Manchin said yes. He soon left for the headquarters at the mine to learn more.

3 hours later, the families found out the awful truth. Only 1 miner survived and his condition is critical. Sadly, the newspaperman was slower in his discovery and today’s front pages are a cruel mockery.

Click the images to enlarge.

If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my site. Thanks for visiting!

Comments

Tom
6:52 pm - 4 January 2006

What a terrible ordeal for these families; I grew up in Sago, about a mile from this mine–our family knows (not well) one of the dead; mom is the postmaster at Tallmansville.

Went down yesterday to see and try to offer some small comfort, to let the folks there know that their neighbors cared.

This whole event has been so surreal–I’ve driven all over that area over the years and feel familiar with that mine. This is just so tragic on so many different levels.

[…] Will Stewart talks about the ultimate media mishap in what they reported as a “miracle in West Virginia.” Nailed it perfectly, Mr. Stewart. http://williamstewart.org/2006/west-virginia/false-hope-on-the-front-page/ […]

4:59 pm - 13 March 2006

dpakse

hdjzi

Add your comment

Don't forget to
stay on topic,
play nice,
not be snarky,
obey all rules,
or your comment will
magically disappear.




Add your comment (see what others are saying)




Subscribe without commenting

William Stewart
William Stewart served 5 years as aide to leading West Virginia Senators and is a leading online commentator in West Virginia politics.

This site is where over 40,000 people come each month to get the latest political news and commentary [...]

Related posts
Subscribe