31 March 2005


Terri Schiavo is Dead

Category
General

Topic
none

At approximately 10:00 AM EST, Terri Schiavo died. There are no reports so far in the mainstream news.

Update:
My Way News is now reporting her death.

News Flash:
As Schiavo’s neared her last moments, her husband denied her parents the comfort of being by her side.

“‘It is with great sadness that it has been reported to us that Terri Schiavo has passed away,’ Paul O’Donnell, a Franciscan monk who acts as spokesman for the parents, said.

“He said the parents and other close family had been allowed into the room after the woman’s death.

“‘They’ve been requesting, as you know, for the last hour to try to be in there. And they were denied access by Michael Schiavo.’”

(AFP/Reuters, “Terri Schiavo dies in Florida”, ABC News Online, 1 April 2005, online)

Commentary:
“This probate judge apparently reasoned that (1) since guardians have the power to withhold fluids from persons in irreversible coma, and (2) since they have the power to withhold medical treatments in general, then (3) they therefore have the power to withhold fluids from patients who are awake, possibly responsive, and able to swallow. This is madness.

“This strange conclusion requires that attempts at normal drinking be construed as a medical treatment. But the judge went even farther into the abyss. He . . . er . . . reasoned that to drink normally would be an experimental procedure, and thus he chose to forbid it. To rebut decisively the claim that dehydration is peaceful and painless, we merely need to ask its advocates to apply it to murderers on death row.

“To withhold minimal comfort measures such as water is gratuitous cruelty. But the judge must be convinced of his probity and rectitude, for he alerted every sheriff in Florida to be vigilant in preventing a chip of ice from entering Terri’s mouth. And appellate courts declined to interfere with this travesty of justice on the grounds that proper procedures were followed. Thus they became complicit in the evolving tragedy.”

(William Anderson, “It Is Ended”, The Weekly Standard, 31 March 2005, online)

Comments


Add your comment (see what others are saying)




Subscribe without commenting

William Stewart
William Stewart served 5 years as aide to leading West Virginia Senators and is a leading online commentator in West Virginia politics.

This site is where over 40,000 people come each month to get the latest political news and commentary [...]

Related posts
Subscribe